Fishers Homeowner’s Guide to Choosing the Right Fence Material for Their Needs: A Comprehensive Comparison of Cedar, Aluminum, and Vinyl

by | Dec 15, 2023 | Aluminum Fence, Cedar Fencing, Chain Link Fencing, Fishers, Picket Fences

Getting Started with Your Fishers Fence Installation

When it comes to fencing your property in Fishers, the options can seem overwhelming. Homeowners often find themselves torn between various materials, each offering its unique benefits. In this post, we will discuss the pros and cons of three popular fencing materials – cedar, aluminum, and vinyl. Our goal is to provide you with all the necessary information to make an informed decision that aligns with your fencing needs and preferences.

Cedar Fencing – Natural Beauty and Durability

Cedar fencing stands out as a top choice for homeowners in Fishers who value natural aesthetics and durability in their outdoor spaces. This material’s distinct characteristics offer a range of benefits but also comeCedar fence with upper trellis design for an English garden feel. with certain maintenance requirements that are essential to consider.


The Advantages of Cedar Fencing

Natural Aesthetics: One of the most appealing aspects of cedar is its natural beauty. The warm tones and unique grain patterns of cedar wood add an organic, rustic charm to any property. This aesthetic appeal makes cedar a popular choice for those who wish to enhance their home’s exterior with a material that complements the natural environment.

Resistance to Rot and Insects: Cedar wood is inherently resistant to rot and insect damage, thanks to its natural oils. These oils act as a deterrent to common pests like termites and prevent the wood from deteriorating due to moisture and fungal growth. This resistance is a significant advantage for homeowners in Fishers, where varying weather conditions can impact the longevity of outdoor materials.

Longevity with Proper Maintenance: With appropriate care, a cedar fence can last between 15 to 30 years. This longevity is a testament to cedar’s robustness as a fencing material. It withstands the test of time and elements, especially when maintained correctly, making it a long-term investment for your property.

The Cons of Cedar Fencing

While cedar fencing offers numerous benefits, there are some drawbacks to consider.

Regular Maintenance Required: To preserve its natural beauty and durability, cedar fencing requires regular maintenance. This involves staining or sealing the wood every few years. The process of staining or sealing not only enhances the wood’s resistance to weather and aging but also helps retain its color and prevents it from turning gray.

Cedar fencing offers a beautiful, durable option for homeowners in Fishers, balancing its natural aesthetics and resistance to elements with the need for regular maintenance. When considering cedar for your fencing needs, weigh these factors to ensure it aligns with your lifestyle and budget requirements.

Aluminum Fencing – Elegant and Low Maintenance

Aluminum fencing is an increasingly popular choice for homeowners in Fishers due to its combination of durability, style, and ease of maintenance. This material offers a modern solution to fencing needs, balancing its unique advantages with some considerations that homeowners should be aware of.

Advantages of Aluminum Fencing

Aluminum FencingRust-Resistant and Weatherproof: A standout feature of aluminum fencing is its exceptional resistance to rust and weather-related damage. Unlike iron or steel, aluminum does not corrode or rust when exposed to moisture or environmental elements. This makes it an ideal choice for Fishers’ varied climate, ensuring that the fence remains in pristine condition for years without succumbing to the typical wear and tear that affects other metal fencing materials.

Variety of Styles and Colors: Aluminum fences come in a wide range of styles and colors, providing ample flexibility to match any home’s architectural style or landscaping theme. From the classic wrought-iron look to more contemporary designs, aluminum fencing can be tailored to suit any aesthetic preference. The availability of different colors also allows homeowners to choose a fence that complements their home’s exterior and landscape design, enhancing the overall curb appeal of the property.

Minimal Upkeep: One of the most appealing aspects of aluminum fencing is its low maintenance requirements. Unlike wood, which needs regular staining or sealing, or iron, which may require rust treatment, aluminum fences need little more than an occasional cleaning to keep them looking new. This ease of maintenance is a significant time and cost saver for homeowners, making aluminum fencing a convenient and practical choice for busy lifestyles.

Considerations for Aluminum Fencing

Less Privacy: Aluminum fencing typically offers less privacy than solid materials like wood or vinyl. Its design often includes gaps between the rails, making it more suitable for decorative or boundary fencing rather than privacy purposes. For homeowners prioritizing privacy, this could be a significant consideration.

Quality: Not all aluminum fencing is created equal. There are a range of aluminum fencing suppliers and the difference in quality can be steep. If you’re gathering quotes, ask questions about the quality of the aluminum fencing.

Aluminum fencing offers a robust, stylish, and low-maintenance option for homeowners in Fishers. Its rust resistance, variety of styles, and minimal upkeep make it a smart investment, despite a potentially higher initial cost and less privacy. By considering these factors, homeowners can make an informed decision about whether aluminum fencing is the right choice for their property.

Vinyl Fencing – Versatility and Ease of Care

Vinyl fencing has emerged as a highly favored option for many homeowners in Fishers, offering a blend of durability, aesthetic versatility, and ease of upkeep. This material is well-suited for those looking for a long-lasting fencing solution that requires minimal maintenance. However, there are some aspects to consider before making a decision.

Advantages of Vinyl Fencing

Durability Against Elements: A significant advantage of vinyl fencing is its resistance to common problems that affect other fencing materials. Unlike wood, vinyl does not rot, warp, or splinter over time. This resistance to natural decay makes vinyl an excellent choice for homeowners looking for a long-term fencing solution. The material’s durability ensures that it maintains its structural integrity and appearance over the years, regardless of weather conditions in Fishers.


Variety in Design and Color: Vinyl fencing offers a wide array of styles and colors, allowing homeowners to tailor their fences to their specific aesthetic preferences. Whether you are looking for a fence that mimics the traditional look of wood or prefer something more contemporary, vinyl offers the flexibility to meet various design needs. The available color options also mean that you can choose a fence that complements your home’s exterior and landscaping, enhancing the overall visual appeal of your property.


Low Maintenance Requirements: One of the most appealing aspects of vinyl fencing is its low-maintenance nature. Unlike wood fencing, which requires regular treatments and repairs, vinyl fencing needs only occasional cleaning with soap and water to maintain its appearance. This ease of maintenance is a significant advantage for those who prefer a ‘set it and forget it’ type of fencing solution, saving both time and money in the long run.

Considerations for Vinyl Fencing

Sensitivity to Extreme Temperatures: Vinyl can be susceptible to damage in extreme temperatures. In very cold weather, vinyl may become brittle and more prone to cracking or breaking upon impact. Conversely, in extremely hot conditions, it can soften or warp. While these issues are not common in the moderate climate of Fishers, they are factors to consider if your area experiences severe temperature fluctuations.

Vinyl fencing offers a robust, stylish, and easy-to-maintain option for homeowners in Fishers. Its resistance to rotting and splintering, variety of design options, and low maintenance needs make it an appealing choice, despite the potential for a higher initial cost and temperature sensitivity. By weighing these factors, homeowners can determine if vinyl fencing is the ideal choice for their property needs.

Choosing the Right Fence Material in Fishers, Indiana

Choosing the right fence material for your home in Fishers involves balancing aesthetic preferences, durability, maintenance requirements, and budget. Cedar, aluminum, and vinyl each offer unique advantages. Consider your priorities and consult with a fencing expert to make the best choice for your property.

For more information and assistance with fence installation in Fishers, visit Draper Fencing Company. We provide expert advice and installation services to help you select and install the perfect fence for your home.

Ready to choose the perfect fence for your Fishers home? Contact Draper Fencing Company today for a consultation and bring your vision to life!

Pete Cowden

Pete Cowden

Director of Sales and Operations

Pete Cowden grew up on the west side of Indianapolis. He attended St Michael’s School from kindergarten through eighth grade before going to North Central High School. Pete won a state championship in Rugby and graduated with an Indiana Honors diploma from North Central in 2007.

After graduating high school, Pete joined the Army. He served three tours of duty as a US Army Ranger. Eventually his injuries built up leading to a medical retirement. After retiring from the Army, Pete attended Indiana University Purdue University – Indianapolis. In 2015 Pete graduated with a Bachelor’s of the Arts in International Studies. 

Pete spent some time working with his fellow veterans in Washington D.C as well as right here in Indianapolis before moving into the fencing industry. Pete began working for Draper Fencing Company in 2021. 

Initially Pete worked primarily as an estimator. He learned quickly the challenges fence installers face and how to overcome them. He constantly gathered feedback from his crews to ensure he was setting them and the customer up for success. 

Pete now manages the entire company. He has managed the building of millions of dollars of fencing projects from small downtown yards to large commercial projects. Draper Fencing Company installs a wide range of products from commercial chain link to ornate custom cedar fences. Pete leads a production department that has over forty five years of fence building experience.

A big part of managing the company is making sure he understands not just how to build a fence but knowing what customers want. He stays up to date on permitting and code enforcement. Part of his job now is to put his years of experience into writing blogs on our website. We strive to communicate clearly and effectively with our customers and our blog posts are an extension of that.