Find Your Perfect Fence Style in Indianapolis

by | Jun 16, 2023 | Fencing, indianapolis

As one of America’s largest cities, Indianapolis, the 14th largest city in the US, covers over 360 square miles. Its diverse neighborhoods, each with their unique styles and flavors, are what make the city vibrant and distinctive. At Draper Fencing Company, we’ve mastered the art of tailoring over 30 fence styles to each neighborhood’s character.

Vintage Charm with Modern Materials in Historic Districts

Many of Indianapolis’s historic districts like Fountain Square and Meridian Kessler hold fencing codes to maintain their architectural style. “Wrought iron style” fencing is popular in these areas. Aluminum, with its wide array of styles that mimic wrought iron, is the preferred material today. Here are a few examples:


Chic aluminum Speartop fence adding elegance to a historic district home.

Flat Top with Spear

Flat Top with Spear aluminum fence blending seamlessly into a historic neighborhood

Finial Top with Decorative Ball Caps & Circles

Finial Top with Decorative Ball Caps & Circles fence complementing a classic architectural style.

Cedar Fencing: French Gothic Posts

Scalloping and French Gothic posts are two design elements commonly incorporated into cedar fences to enhance their aesthetic appeal, particularly in areas aiming to maintain an antique or vintage ambiance.

Scalloping, also referred to as a “dip” or “curve” in the fence line, is a design technique where the tops of the fence panels dip down in a concave manner between the posts, creating a wavy appearance to the top edge of the fence. This unique design adds a touch of elegance and softness to a straight-lined cedar fence. It can create a less imposing look while still maintaining privacy, and it evokes a sense of nostalgia, reminiscent of older, countryside properties.

French Gothic Posts:
The French Gothic style is characterized by its pointed top, a design that is reminiscent of Gothic architecture from historical European structures. When applied to fence posts, it results in a distinct pointed top, often resembling a spearhead or arrow. This style can be seen on both the main fence posts and sometimes even on the individual pickets. French Gothic posts add an element of sophistication and are a nod to historical designs, making them an ideal choice for areas wishing to preserve or evoke an antique feel.

When combined, scalloping and French Gothic posts create a cedar fence that is not only functional in providing privacy but is also artistically pleasing. Cedar wood itself is a durable, aromatic, and naturally rot-resistant material, making it a popular choice for fencing. Adding these design elements elevates the appearance of the fence, allowing property owners to marry the benefits of modern cedar material with the timeless charm of antique design.

Scalloping and French Gothic posts
The popular Cap N Trim Cedar Privacy fence in Broad RippleModern Meets Vintage in Older Neighborhoods

Some older neighborhoods like Broad Ripple preserve their “village” feel with a variety of Cedar privacy fences. Our top-rated Cedar Privacy fence, Cap N Trim, has adorned a few homes along the Monon trail.

Historic neighborhoods often aim to retain their unique character, and Broad Ripple is no exception. Known for its distinctive “village” ambiance, Broad Ripple seamlessly blends the past with the present. One way this neighborhood achieves this is through the careful selection of architectural and design elements, among which Cedar privacy fences stand out.

Cedar Privacy Fences:
Cedar wood is celebrated for its durability, natural aroma, and resistance to decay and pests. Beyond its functional benefits, Cedar fences offer a timeless aesthetic appeal. They possess a warm, reddish-brown hue which can turn to a distinguished silvery gray with age. This makes Cedar an excellent choice for older neighborhoods that wish to keep a touch of historical charm while ensuring the longevity of their structures.

Cap N Trim Cedar Privacy Fence:
The Cap N Trim Cedar privacy fence is a particularly sought-after design, renowned for its top-notch quality and elegant appearance. This design features a ‘cap’ or top board that runs horizontally across the fence’s top edge, providing a finished look. The ‘trim’ component refers to the trim boards that are often placed below the cap, enhancing the fence’s aesthetic appeal by adding depth and detail.

The presence of Cap N Trim Cedar fences along the Monon trail showcases the neighborhood’s commitment to preserving its aesthetic legacy while embracing contemporary styles. The Monon trail, being a significant pathway, sees many visitors, and having homes adorned with these fences adds to the trail’s visual appeal.

Cap N Trim Cedar Privacy Fence

Cap N Trim Cedar privacy fence on a picturesque property

Cedar Industrial Style Fence

Cedar “Industrial” style fence combines a modern look with a vintage feel, ideal for post-war 1950’s style neighborhoods.

The “Industrial” style, in architectural and design terms, is often characterized by a raw, unfinished look, drawing inspiration from warehouses and urban factories. When combined with the natural charm of Cedar wood, the Cedar “Industrial” style fence emerges as a compelling design element that beautifully marries modern aesthetics with a touch of nostalgia.

Cedar Wood: Cedar, a timeless choice for fencing, brings to the table its inherent durability, resistance to decay, and a pleasant aroma. The wood’s rich and warm hues, which age gracefully over time, can juxtapose brilliantly against the stark and rugged features often associated with industrial design.

Features of Cedar “Industrial” Style Fence: Typically, this style might incorporate elements like:

  1. Metal Accents: Combining Cedar wood with metal elements, like steel or iron frames, brackets, or rivets, which evoke that raw, industrial feel.
  2. Clean Lines: A hallmark of modern design, the fence would emphasize straight, clean lines, providing a neat and streamlined appearance.
  3. Exposed Hardware: Rather than hiding bolts, nails, or other hardware, the industrial design might showcase them, turning functional elements into design features.
  4. Mixed Materials: Beyond just metal, the fence might also integrate other materials like concrete or wire mesh to further enhance the industrial feel.

Perfect for 1950’s Style Neighborhoods: The post-war 1950s era in architecture saw a blend of simplicity and functionality. As the world was recovering from the devastation of World War II, there was a significant push towards industrialization and urban development. The Cedar “Industrial” style fence, with its nod to both the past and the present, fits perfectly into such neighborhoods. It pays homage to the industrial spirit of the era while updating it with contemporary sensibilities.

Cedar industrial style fence with a modern appeal.

Horizontal w Trim Fence

The Bates-Hendricks neighborhood, situated near downtown, is emblematic of many urban areas experiencing a renaissance. As old houses and structures undergo renovations and rejuvenations, there’s an evident trend towards merging historical charm with modern design. Amidst this backdrop, the Horizontal w Trim fence style has become a standout choice, capturing the contemporary essence many homeowners and developers seek.

Bates-Hendricks’ Renovation Boom: In neighborhoods like Bates-Hendricks, the influx of young professionals, artists, and families looking to be closer to downtown amenities has spurred a renovation movement. These renovations often aim to preserve the historical integrity of older homes while infusing them with modern conveniences and aesthetics. As a result, exterior design elements like fencing play a pivotal role in achieving this balance.

Horizontal w Trim Fence Style: The Horizontal w Trim fence style is a fresh take on traditional fencing. Here’s what sets it apart:

  1. Horizontal Boards: Unlike the common vertical pickets seen in many fences, this design employs horizontal boards, offering a streamlined, contemporary look. The horizontal lines can make spaces feel larger and more open.
  2. Trim Detailing: The addition of trim serves a dual purpose. Firstly, it adds an element of sophistication and finish to the fence. Secondly, it provides structural support, ensuring that the horizontal boards remain straight and true over time.
  3. Versatility: The simple yet chic design can complement a range of architectural styles, from mid-century modern to more traditional homes that have been updated with a contemporary twist.

Growing Popularity: As Bates-Hendricks and similar neighborhoods lean into modern design elements that still respect the area’s history, the Horizontal w Trim fence style has found its niche. Its clean lines and refined appearance resonate with those looking for a contemporary touch without sacrificing the warmth and coziness that wood fencing traditionally offers.

Modern horizontal Cedar fence with trim

Cedar Fence with Trellis

Irvington, situated on the east side, stands out as a neighborhood with a distinctive aura, reminiscent of quaint English villages. The ambiance of such neighborhoods, where cobblestone streets might meander past historic homes surrounded by lush gardens, invites design elements that evoke a sense of old-world charm. In this setting, the Cedar with Trellis fence design has become a much-adored feature, resonating perfectly with the “English Garden” aesthetic.

Irvington’s “English Garden” Vibe: An “English Garden” feel is characterized by its organic, curated chaos. This gardening style showcases a tapestry of colorful blooms, structured pathways, and often incorporates water features or statues. The gardens have an intimate, inviting ambiance, enticing visitors to wander and explore. Irvington, with its mature trees, historic buildings, and love for lush landscaping, naturally leans into this style.

Cedar with Trellis Look: The Cedar with Trellis fence design complements the “English Garden” atmosphere in several ways:

  1. Natural Cedar: Cedar wood, with its rich hues and aromatic presence, exudes a rustic charm. Its durability and resistance to pests and decay make it not only an aesthetically pleasing choice but also a practical one.
  2. Trellis Feature: A trellis is a latticed framework, often used as a decorative piece or as a support for climbing plants. When integrated into a fence, the trellis not only adds an ornamental element but also serves as a canvas for climbing roses, ivy, or other vining plants, further enhancing the “English Garden” feel.
  3. Integration with Nature: The Cedar with Trellis design seamlessly marries the built environment with nature. As plants grow up and through the trellis, the fence becomes a living part of the garden.
  4. Versatility: While the Cedar with Trellis design has a vintage appeal, it also lends itself well to modern interpretations, making it suitable for a range of home styles.

Growing Affection: For neighborhoods like Irvington that prioritize a blend of history and natural beauty, the Cedar with Trellis look serves as a bridge between the built and natural environments. As residents seek to create outdoor spaces that are both functional and enchanting, this fence style emerges as a clear favorite, encapsulating the very essence of an “English Garden” in its design.

Cedar fence with upper trellis design for an English garden feel.

Cedar Fence with Trellis and Arch

Gates play a crucial role in setting the tone for a property’s overall aesthetic, acting as both a functional entry point and a statement piece. For homeowners and designers looking to evoke an old-world charm reminiscent of the English countryside, adding arches to gates can be a transformative design choice.

The Appeal of Arches: Arches have been a staple in architecture and design for millennia. From ancient Roman aqueducts to Gothic cathedrals, the arch has consistently been a symbol of strength, grandeur, and timeless beauty.

  1. Old English Ambiance: The old English design aesthetic often incorporates arches, especially in elements like doorways, windows, and bridges. In the context of gates, an arch offers a hint of the romantic, reminiscent of English cottages, castles, and manor homes.
  2. Softening Lines: The gentle curve of an arch contrasts beautifully with the often linear and angular design of fences and walls. This can soften the overall appearance of an entrance, making it more inviting.
  3. Structural Integrity: Beyond aesthetics, arches have been historically revered for their structural benefits. The curved design helps distribute weight and can enhance the longevity of the gate.

Customizing with Arches: While some gate designs inherently incorporate arches, many standard gates can be customized to include an arched top. This flexibility allows homeowners to retrofit existing gates or design new ones that perfectly match their vision.

Cedar Fence with Trellis and Arch

Blending in with Nature in Open Neighborhoods

While Indianapolis is often recognized for its bustling urban environment, pockets of pastoral tranquility remain, particularly in areas near Eagle Creek and Zionsville. These neighborhoods, with their sprawling landscapes and remnants of a bygone agricultural era, provide a serene contrast to the city’s fast-paced energy. For residents in these areas, the choice of fencing becomes crucial, both as a reflection of the rural ambiance and as a functional feature. Enter the Dog Run fence design, a solution that strikes the perfect balance.

The Dog Run Fence Design: Designed with both aesthetics and functionality in mind, the Dog Run fence becomes an ideal choice for such settings. Here’s why:

  1. Rustic Appeal: The Dog Run fence often incorporates natural materials, such as wood, which aligns with the rural aesthetic of the surrounding landscape. Its design can be simple yet sturdy, echoing the practicality of farm structures.
  2. Security for Pets: As the name suggests, this fence is tailored for pet owners. It provides a secure boundary to ensure pets, especially dogs, can roam freely without wandering off. The design typically ensures that gaps are minimal, preventing smaller pets from squeezing through.
  3. Versatility: While its primary function might be to contain pets, the Dog Run fence can also serve as a boundary for gardens, play areas, or even livestock, making it a multifunctional choice for residents who might have varied needs.
  4. Integration with Landscape: The design can be easily integrated with the existing landscape, whether it’s alongside a barn, bordering a vegetable garden, or encircling a homestead. This ensures that the fence doesn’t feel out of place but rather complements the overall environment.

Dog Run Fence Design

Dog run fence design keeping an agricultural feel.

Experience the Draper Fencing Company Difference

No matter what your neighborhood’s fencing requirements are, Draper Fencing Company has a style you’ll love. Our team will help you choose your dream fence, building every fence custom on site for the perfect fit. Every person you interact with, from start to finish, is an integral part of Draper Fencing. We never subcontract and stand by our work with both Craftsmanship and Material Warranties. Discover how a new fence can enhance your home and neighborhood today.

Pete Cowden

Pete Cowden

Director of Sales and Operations

Pete Cowden grew up on the west side of Indianapolis. He attended St Michael’s School from kindergarten through eighth grade before going to North Central High School. Pete won a state championship in Rugby and graduated with an Indiana Honors diploma from North Central in 2007.

After graduating high school, Pete joined the Army. He served three tours of duty as a US Army Ranger. Eventually his injuries built up leading to a medical retirement. After retiring from the Army, Pete attended Indiana University Purdue University – Indianapolis. In 2015 Pete graduated with a Bachelor’s of the Arts in International Studies. 

Pete spent some time working with his fellow veterans in Washington D.C as well as right here in Indianapolis before moving into the fencing industry. Pete began working for Draper Fencing Company in 2021. 

Initially Pete worked primarily as an estimator. He learned quickly the challenges fence installers face and how to overcome them. He constantly gathered feedback from his crews to ensure he was setting them and the customer up for success. 

Pete now manages the entire company. He has managed the building of millions of dollars of fencing projects from small downtown yards to large commercial projects. Draper Fencing Company installs a wide range of products from commercial chain link to ornate custom cedar fences. Pete leads a production department that has over forty five years of fence building experience.

A big part of managing the company is making sure he understands not just how to build a fence but knowing what customers want. He stays up to date on permitting and code enforcement. Part of his job now is to put his years of experience into writing blogs on our website. We strive to communicate clearly and effectively with our customers and our blog posts are an extension of that.